Seven Questions That Separate HVAC Companies in St. Charles County
Last winter a homeowner in St. Peters called us for a second opinion. Another company had told her she needed a full system replacement. Her furnace was fourteen years old, so the recommendation wasn't crazy on its face.
The part that was failing cost a few hundred dollars. The unit had another several years in it, easily. She asked me how she was supposed to have known that, and I didn't have a good answer except: ask better questions.
So that's what this is. Seven questions I'd want a homeowner to ask me, including the ones I'd rather not be asked. If you're sorting through heating and cooling companies in St. Charles, O'Fallon, St. Peters, Cottleville or Lake St. Louis, these will tell you more in ten minutes than a week of reading reviews.
1. "What exactly is failing, and what are my options besides replacement?"
Watch for a specific component and a specific reason. A cracked heat exchanger, a failed inducer motor, a compressor that's drawing locked-rotor amps — these are findable, nameable things. "It's just old" is not a diagnosis.
You should get a repair number and a replace number, both written down, even when repair is clearly the worse buy. A company that won't quote the repair is making the decision for you.
There's a legitimate case for replacement, and I make it regularly — when the repair cost approaches a third of a new system, when the unit uses R-22, when the thing has already failed twice. But I should be able to explain which of those applies to your unit.
2. "Will you do a load calculation, and can I see it?"
If a replacement is on the table, this is non-negotiable. A load calculation measures what your house actually needs, room by room — insulation, windows, ceiling height, duct runs, which way the house faces.
The "can I see it" half of the question matters as much as the first half. A company that does real calculations has a document to hand you. One that sizes off the old equipment's data plate has nothing to show.
I'd add one thing most people don't know to ask: whether the ductwork was evaluated too. Equipment and duct are one system. A 96% efficient furnace pushing air through leaky, undersized ducts will not deliver 96% of anything to your living room.
3. "Who installs it — your employees or a subcontractor?"
Neither answer disqualifies a company. But you deserve to know, and the follow-up is the real question: does the crew that installs it also do the maintenance?
Ask it that way. "Are you licensed?" gets a yes from everyone.
When installers know they'll be back in that basement every fall, the work gets done differently. Nobody wants to spend ten years crawling past their own sloppy duct transition. Our installers are our people, and they rotate through maintenance. That isn't generosity, it's accountability with a schedule attached.
4. "What does the labor warranty cover, and for how long?"
Almost everyone asks about "the warranty" and stops there. There are two, and they behave completely differently.
The manufacturer's warranty covers parts, usually ten years if the equipment gets registered — ask whether they handle registration, because an unregistered unit often drops to five. That coverage travels with the equipment no matter who installed it.
The labor warranty is the contractor's own promise, and it runs anywhere from one year to ten. This is the one that costs you real money later, because in year seven a free compressor still comes with a bill for the refrigerant and the hours.
Get both in writing, with the duration spelled out.
5. "Are you licensed and permitted for this, and will you pull the permit?"
Permits feel like paperwork until you sell the house and a buyer's inspector finds unpermitted mechanical work.
Municipalities across our service area handle this differently, and a company working here every day knows which jurisdiction wants what. A company that offers to skip the permit to save you a little is telling you something about how it handles the things you can't see.
6. "What's your maintenance program, and what's actually in it?"
Ask for the task list, not the brochure. A real tune-up includes combustion analysis on the heating side, static pressure readings, amp draws on the motors, a capacitor test, refrigerant charge verified against the actual conditions rather than topped off by feel.
Then ask the uncomfortable one: what happens if I decline the maintenance plan? If the answer involves your warranty being affected, read the fine print before you agree to anything.
Our service club membership exists because systems that get looked at twice a year fail less and last longer. That's it. It isn't a subscription trap.
One customer described what consistency looks like better than our marketing does:
"Austin feels like a friend at this point. He's always the one that comes for my HVAC checks and he's always friendly and informative. Great service."
— AAA Customer
Notice what she's describing: the same technician, repeatedly, who knows her system. You can't build that with a rotating subcontractor pool, and it's the thing that catches a problem in October instead of January.
7. "Can you service what I have if I don't buy from you?"
This one's a loyalty test in reverse.
A company that only services the brand it sells has a conflict baked in. When your Carrier unit needs a decision, "we don't really work on those" becomes an argument for replacement that has nothing to do with your furnace.
We're a Platinum American Standard Dealer and we service American Standard, Carrier, Lennox, Trane, Goodman, York, Amana, Bryant, Armstrong, Intertherm and Mitsubishi. The practical effect is that when I tell you to repair rather than replace, there's no reason to doubt me.
The answers to listen for
Across all seven, the pattern matters more than any single response. You're listening for specificity. Named parts. Documents you can see. Numbers with durations attached. A willingness to quote the option that makes them less money.
Vagueness isn't always dishonesty — sometimes it's a salesperson who genuinely doesn't know. From your side of the kitchen table, the difference doesn't help you much.
Where AAA fits
We've answered these questions in homes across St. Charles, St. Louis, Lincoln and Warren Counties since 1970, and we'd rather be asked them than not. We're a Platinum American Standard Dealer for new furnace installation and new air conditioner installation, we do furnace repair and maintenance tune-ups on every major brand, and we install Mitsubishi ductless systems where ductwork doesn't reach. On the air quality side we carry Aprilaire humidifiers, the Haven monitor, the Air Scrubber and American Standard's ventilation equipment. There are Ameren Missouri rebates worth knowing about, financing if you need it, and a Fair and Honest Pricing Guarantee that I'm personally accountable for. Ask us all seven at (636) 397-3200.
Frequently asked questions
What questions should I ask an HVAC company before replacing my furnace?
Ask what specific component is failing and what the repair option costs, whether they will perform and show you a load calculation, whether installers are employees or subcontractors, what the labor warranty covers and for how long, whether they pull permits, what their maintenance program actually includes, and whether they service brands they do not sell. Specific answers signal competence.
How do I know if I need a furnace repair or a full replacement?
Get both numbers in writing. Replacement generally makes sense when the repair approaches roughly a third of a new system's cost, when the unit uses discontinued R-22 refrigerant, or when it has failed repeatedly. A fourteen-year-old furnace with one failed part is often worth repairing. A company that refuses to quote the repair is deciding for you.
What is the difference between a parts warranty and a labor warranty?
The manufacturer's parts warranty covers components, typically ten years on registered equipment, and follows the equipment regardless of who installed it. The labor warranty is the contractor's own and ranges from one to ten years. Labor is what costs you money later, since a covered part still arrives with a bill for refrigerant and hours.
Does my new HVAC system need to be registered for the warranty?
Yes, in most cases. Manufacturers commonly reduce coverage from ten years to five on unregistered equipment, and registration windows are typically sixty to ninety days after installation. Ask whether the installing company handles registration for you and request confirmation once it is filed, since this is a frequent and expensive oversight.
Do HVAC companies need to pull a permit for a furnace replacement?
Generally yes for equipment replacement involving gas, electrical or venting work, though requirements vary by municipality across St. Charles and St. Louis Counties. Unpermitted mechanical work commonly surfaces during a home sale inspection and becomes the seller's problem. A contractor who offers to skip the permit is signaling how it handles work you cannot inspect.
Should ductwork be inspected when replacing a furnace or air conditioner?
Yes. Equipment and ducts function as one system, so a high-efficiency furnace moving air through leaky or undersized ductwork will not deliver its rated performance to your rooms. A thorough replacement quote evaluates duct condition, sizing and sealing, and says plainly whether duct work is included in the price or excluded from it.








